Showing posts with label Media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Media. Show all posts

Friday, 22 July 2011

Errors in Media Reporting on the Greek Bail-out Crisis


A very brief post from Limassol, Cyprus. The errors or misleading statements in the media this past week on the Greek debt crisis are simply astounding. Here are only a few examples: 

The Sun: Grecian Earner: The deal was hammered out at a nine-hour session - and comes 14 months after Greece, which is more than £300billion in debt, was given its first £100billion cash injection.

Ø  This is wrong, or misleading: Greece has only received approximately EUR 50 billion of the first bail-out package of EUR 110 billion. This is UKP 44 bln out of UKP 96.9 bln. The full “£100billion” hasn’t been disbursed.

The New York Times, After a Deal, Only More Challenges, 21 July 2011: It includes 109 billion euros ($157 billion) in aid to Greece.

Ø  This is not aid to Greece, it is a mix of new sovereign loans or private sector loan roll-overs. This ignores the whole question: can Greece repay its old and new loans?

The BBC: EU austerity drive country by country, 20 July 2011: But the Greek government has not delivered on a major element of the rescue plan - large-scale privatisation. The goal is to raise 50bn euros from sales of state assets by 2015.

Ø  This is a true statement, but fundamentally a wrong one. The government passed the EUR 50 billion privatisation package in June 2011, about three weeks ago. Of course the package hasn’t been implemented yet.

Nicole Itano in a Bloomberg video Legal Disputes Complicate Greek State Asset Sales, June 28: “There isn’t even a land registry to help sort out the mess.”

Ø  Actually, there is a land registry: you can view it here.  The problem is that there are ownership disputes on some parcels of land, mainly a result of historical factors, tradition and the backlog in the Greek legal system. The other problem is that the registry does not cover all areas, as not everyone has declared their property. Most individual property is already in the land registry.

There are others too numerous to mention. There are also numerous errors regarding the interest rates offered by the private sector: they are higher than the EUR 3.5% offered by the EFSF.

You can view the Eurozone press statement here. Check also the IIF press release. There is precious little by way of detail. I’m still running the numbers – some are very unclear – and hope to post an update over the weekend.

(c) Philip Ammerman, 2011
Navigator Consulting Group Ltd.  

Wednesday, 13 July 2011

The New York Times and the Papandreou Family


The New York Times ran an article on the Papandreou family today (“Family Differences, Global Issues”), which relies heavily on the perspective of Nikos Papandreou, the brother of the current Prime Minister of Greece, George Papandreou.

It is interesting to note that the word “corruption” is not mentioned a single time in the article. This is arguable one of the greatest legacies of former Prime Minister Andreas Papandreou's rule, and one which George Papandreou, the son of Andreas and Greece's current prime minister, struggles with today.

There is no mention of the Bank of Crete scandal, in which $210 million were embezzled. Some of these millions were, according to the Bank’s Chief Executive, paid directly to Andreas Papandreou. Although the former Prime Minister was acquitted by a special tribunal, there are few people who do not believe he was involved, that senior PASOK figures did not benefit from this, or that the special tribunal properly investigated the affair.

There is no mention of the Siemens bribery scandal, which began during Andreas Papandreou’s term, and according to the report of the Hellenic Parliament (which was supported by PASOK) may have caused the Greek state up to EUR 2 billion in over-priced purchases. Significantly, there is no mention in the article that the Siemens bribery funds allegedly went to PASOK politicians as well as to PASOK as a political party.

There is no mention of the role of Nikos Papandreou, the protagonist in this article, and his rather mysterious role in the negotiations of the Skaramanga Shipyard from Thyssen Krupp to Abu Dhabi Mar in March 2010. Why was Mr. Papandreou involved in this deal when:

a.     He had, and has, no government position. 

b.   The Greek state had no shareholding in Skaramanga at the time. Why was it involved in the negotiating the deal with Abu Dhabi Mar? Was the price paid to--ostensibly--safeguard jobs at Skaramanga worth it? Was this the only motivation?

c.     Why did Prime Minister George Papandreou not only reverse Greek policy not to accept the first batch of four submarines (one of which was defective), but to order two more, at a time when it was clear Greece could not afford the first four, let alone the second second two?

There is no mention of the fact that Mr. Nikos Papandreou’s name has surfaced as well in the failed Astakos Investment, not least as someone doing somersaults:

Κληθείς να σχολιάσει την εμπλοκή του κ. Νίκου Παπανδρέου στην υπόθεση του Αστακού παραπέμπει σε παλαιότερη δήλωση του πρωθυπουργού, ο οποίος είχε πει ότι οι προσωπικές και συγγενικές σχέσεις δεν επηρεάζουν τη λήψη αποφάσεων. Ωστόσο, ο κ. Παμπούκης καλύπτει απόλυτα τον αδελφό του πρωθυπουργού, καθώς όπως λέει «ο κ. Νίκος Παπανδρέου έχει πει ότι θα έκανε και “κωλοτούμπες” για να φέρει επενδύσεις στην Ελλάδα. Και εγώ λέω ότι πολύ καλά θα έκανε, διότι η χώρα τις χρειάζεται περισσότερο από ποτέ».

I will leave the NYT to attempt to decipher this Greek text on their own—it may be instructive.

Somersaults or no, if I had done the interview, I would have asked at least these simple questions: How is it possible that the brother of the Prime Minister, who does not hold government office, and has no apparent qualifications in investment management, represent Greece at this level? Isn't there a conflict of interest? Doesn't the Prime Minister trust his own Ministers Pamboukis and Katselli who were involved in the negotiations? 

There is also no mention of Mr. Antrikos Papandreou, the other brother of Nikos and George, who is founder and head of the Institute for Climate and Energy Security. This organisation not only benefits from contracts from the Greek government, notably the organisation of the Mediterranean Climate Change Initiative, but is apparently lobbying for the creation of a EUR 200 million investment fund for green energy investments.

There is no mention of the fact that Prime Minister Papandreou’s PASOK party is highly indebted, that it has pre-absorbed its government funding until 2016, and that it has over EUR 40 million in bank loans. Together with its implication in known corruption scandals (the Siemens funds), one has to wonder exactly how much negotiating power Greece’s Prime Minister has when he attends these European meetings in Brussels and Berlin.

As Greece tries to clean up the mess inflicted by two generations of venal and corrupt politicians and their allies, this historical perspective would have been valuable, more so than the anodyne comments made by former Minister Louka Katseli. Andreas Papandreou's dark legacy continues to this day, and it is this legacy that his son, who was an active Minister in his father's governments, is called upon to change.  

© Philip Ammerman, 2011

Sunday, 10 July 2011

Greece, Renewable Energy Investments and the New York Times

The New York Times recently published another article on Greece which provides an extremely biased viewpoint and reveals an unsettling lack of knowledge of the underlying business economics and realities of the topic under investigation.

In “Struggling to Stoke Economic Growth in Greece”, published on June 19, 2011, Liz Alderman describes the alleged government’s reaction of Mr. George Peristeris, Chief Executive of GEK Terna, as follows:

So when George Peristeris, the chief executive of Gek Terna, a large energy company, wanted to plow funds into an offshore wind project, he thought he would be welcomed with open arms. But it turned out that the government decided it could run things better. “Private investors with money in hand were shut out,” Mr. Peristeris said.

In fact, it is hardly surprising that George Papandreou’s government may have given this reaction right after its election. This is due to the simple fact that even today, the government does not have a fully-integrated strategy for renewable energy. This is a highly complex subject, but it boils down to two essential factors:

a.  Energy generated from renewable sources is between 2x and 4x times more expensive than energy from conventional sources. In Greece, the average price per KW produced by the Public Power Corporation from existing conventional sources (and hydropower) is about 11 cents, while the average price/KW for wind power is approximately 20-25 cents, and for photovoltaic power above 40 cents. Given that renewable energy investments are being financed primarily by a high feed-in tariff, it is no surprise that the government needs to expand generation capacity carefully, in order to avoid excessive investment which would further bankrupt the country.

b.  The challenge of renewable energy investments is not to find available land or offshore areas to place them, but to ensure that they are as close to distribution networks and demand centres as possible. Why? Because (a) electric current transmitted over a distribution line loses power the further it is transmitted, and (b) the costs of connecting power generation units to the distribution grid is expensive, and is the responsibility of the investor. One of the major achievements of the former Minister of Environment and Energy, Ms. Tanya Birbili, was to begin the process of approving an energy map and zoning rules for renewable energy investments, including offshore wind farms. With such guidelines, it is unreasonable and illogical to expect that any investor showing up with his or her own plan would receive approval.

I presume, judging by what has occurred in Greece since the purported time of Mr. Peristeris’ contacts with the government, that things have improved significantly as will be explained below. I also presume that the journalist's task is to investigate this situation, not simply rely on passive reporting. To uncritically transmit the personal experience of a single executive, based on a single reported contact with the government, and then generalise from here to all investors and investments in Greece, is poor journalism to say the least.

This is confirmed by fact that renewable investments in Greece are surging and are among the most successful areas of investment:

·   On September 29, 2010, the Greek Public Power Company announced on a strategic investment of up to EUR 2 billion in renewable energy projects in cooperation with EDF Energies Nouvelles, the renewables energy division of Électricité de France (EDF), the world’s largest electricity generator. This joint venture is studying at least two investments: a 250 MW wind park in Florina as well as a hybrid unit in Crete which includes 90 MW generation with energy storage. EDF and PPC are already cooperating on a 38 MW wind park in Beotia.

·    RF Energy, a private firm, is in the process of installing 21 wind parks in Evoia with a total generating capacity of 579 MW, worth approximately EUR 984 billion. This investment has been underway since 2009.

·   DTS Hellas, a private firm, signed an agreement with China's Dongfang Electric International Corporation on June 6th 2011, for the installation of two wind energy projects, 250 and 750 MW, for a total value of EUR 2.5 billion.

·   The government has greatly expanded the scheme for renewable energy projects, in both photovoltaics and wind energy, concerning both household and commercial power generation. Over EUR 1 billion in projects have been submitted and partially approved since mid-2010. These are “decentralised” projects: they can be submitted by any household or any investor. These calls have been open since mid-2010 and have been widely reporting in the Greek press.

Equally significantly, the Ministry of Development has set up a specific service, the Investor Support Service for Renewable Energy Projects. Together with the Invest in Greece agency, several billion Euros in large-scale projects are currently under review. The government has also passed Law 3851/2010 on renewable energy investments and the acceleration of the licensing process.

None of these investments or regulatory changes is mentioned in the NYT article. Yet taken together, these investments amount of over EUR 10 billion, in a country with a GDP of EUR 220 billion.

Adding insult to injury, the article closes with a quotation from Mr. Demetri Politopoulos, who set up a money-losing brewery in northern Greece, and has apparently become the ultimate authority on investments in Greece for the New York Times:

“What’s happened here in the last few days is Looney Tunes,” said Demetri Politopoulos, chief executive of the Macedonian Thrace Brewery, who himself ran into thickets of regulatory hurdles when he tried to make new investments in Greece. “We’re trying to attract investors? Good luck.”

My opinions on the reason for the failure of this investment and the credibility of its sponsor are seen in my blog entry: “What’s Broken in Greece: Ask an Entrepreneur”.

Again, I have to ask: shouldn’t a responsible journalist seek a fair and balanced opinion on investments in Greece? Shouldn’t a journalist seek out at least one entrepreneur who has actually succeeded in this country? Are failed investment cases the only authority for the New York Times?

I also have to ask why there is such a dearth of objective reporting on Greece. Is it because journalists simply don’t know what they are talking about in terms of business sense? Is it because “fair and balanced”, or “objective journalism” no longer apply? Is it because newspapers have editors who don’t edit? Is it intellectual laziness? Long distance reporting? Bad fixers?

By failing to ask the right questions, interview the right people, and understand the basic business logic of what is being reported, the New York Times is failing its readers and misrepresenting the reputation of a country which, whatever its present difficulties, deserves the benefit of the truth. The fact that this occurs so soon after the Judith Miller scandal on Iraqi Weapons of Mass Destruction indicates that regrettably, little has changed.

© Philip Ammerman, 2011

Tuesday, 15 June 2010

Enjoying Greek Public Television (or not)

I’m increasingly convinced that at least 25% of the “problem” in Greece is the lack of a really good, objective and independent national media. This has always been the case, of course, but I’m not sure this sad situation can or should be allowed to continue given the magnitude of the crisis.

On the “NET” news bulletin today, the final clip just before the athletic bulletin was that of Deputy Minister of Health Fofi Gennimata touring a hospital somewhere, possibly in Boeotia. The clip was footage taken from “Star TV”, one of the more ridiculous Greek channels. The clip was entirely out of synch with anything important going on today: the subject was the functioning of some new piece of equipment.

Does Greek public television, a mammoth public organisation financed by mandatory household taxes, really need to show a “Star TV” clip of the Deputy Health Minister in Boeotia? Why? To assure us that she is actually working? Can’t we be a little more subtle in the political manipulation of the news?

What will PASOK order up next? Reports on Greece’s annual wheat cultivation, proclaiming a record harvest? Or the targets of our next 10-year plan for agricultural tractor production?

A little while later, the ET3 anchor was presenting the hospital – pharmaceutical provider “crisis”. His sentence was to the effect that “patients are being held as hostages (ομηρία) by the pharmaceutical providers.”

Hello? There are companies which are still trying to collect debts which date back to 2007 and before, and who have stopped supplying the public hospitals because they are owed money. Yes, of course there have been lots of scandals regarding the cost of pharmaceuticals and consumables in the public healthcare system. And we know exactly why: so that administrators and doctors would make bribes off the procurement contracts, just as they take bribes (“fakellakia”) to arrange routine medical treatment. Did anyone force the government or the public healthcare system to enter these agreements?

There is a double standard at work:

· When dockworkers close off the ports and prevent tourists from boarding their ships, is this called “ομηρία”?

· When student unionists prevent university staff from leaving or entering their university offices, is this called “ομηρία”?

· When the government delays payments to fire fighters, teachers and social workers on part-time contracts, is this called “ομηρία”?

· When the government unilaterally decides to delay the refund of VAT until September, is this called “ομηρία”?

Of course not. It’s only when the government realises it has to pay, that it’s erstwhile “opponents” become “hostage takers.”

This may sound like a minor issue, given the state of things today. But to me, it shows a sloppy and politicised approach to public broadcasting, which unfortunately reflects the double standards and lassitude of public sector officials today.

It does nothing to contribute to an objective public understanding of critical issues affecting the Greek taxpayer. When adding this to the fact that ERT employs over 3,500 staff, runs at least 8 TV channels, and 5 orchestras, it’s very clear that the public sector reforms are not nearly as comprehensive as they should be. The opposite is true.

Related Posts

Neither PASOK nor ND have a plan to Reform the Public Sector in Greece September 4th, 2009

Tuesday, 11 May 2010

Live your Delirium in Greece

Delirium (noun): a highly disturbed state of mind characterised by restlessness, illusions and incoherent though and speech. Oxford Compact English Dictionary.

Olga Tremi © Mega TV

I was really impressed, for lack of a better term, by the ability of this country’s elites to delude themselves and, by extension, its citizens. The evening news on private and public channels in Greece yesterday contained much the same interpretation of three events: the European Stabilisation Mechanism; the resulting stock market rally; and the defeat of the CDU in the elections of Nordrhein-Westfaellen.

The Eurozone’s decision to adapt the EUR 750 bln European Stabilisation Mechanism was somehow seen as a vindication of Greek policy. “You see?” TV anchors chortled…”Europe finally understood our position against the speculators.” By taking this decisive action, the Euro gained value and the ability of Eurozone governments to borrow more money was safeguarded. The final validation of this event—if it were ever needed—was the stock market rally on the Athens Stock Exchange (up 9.18%) as well as other major exchanges.

Not a single anchor or commentator paused for a moment to consider what this meant. By taking extreme action in the form of loan guarantees and ECB/IMF intervention, Europe’s governments admitted two critical facts:

• That further, extensive debt funding would be needed by the Eurozone members, and that given the state of public finance, this funding could not be assured in the open markets;

• That for the first time, the Eurozone has set up a totally new mechanism of loan guarantees whereby one country guarantees another country’s debts. This decision was taken in a rushed summit meeting without a single reference either to the European Parliament, or the national parliaments of the Eurozone members.

Think for just a moment what this means. On the one hand, it is a tremendous usurpation of national sovereign rights, which normally should stem from a national democratic vote. Under the guise of the crisis, the Eurozone leaders have pushed through a poorly-thought decision which commits the Eurozone countries to a de facto political integration.

On the other hand, the decision creates yet another sovereign lending instrument at the moment we should all be concerned with reducing public sector debt, not increasing it. As with all instruments of this nature, we know it will be absorbed, for the simple reason that it exists. Given the repeated breach of the Maastricht criteria by nearly all members (and Angela Merkel’s recent electoral results in NRW), can you honestly see any country saying “no”? It's so much simpler to say "yes", since the instrument now exists.

The Greek news also portrayed a major benefit of this decision as the strengthening of the Euro. I have to ask why anyone sees this as a positive decision. For the vast majority of ordinary workers and citizens, the Eurozone is an export- and tourism-driven economy. While a devaluation of the Euro will make oil more expensive (it is denominated in US dollars), it will make our exports and domestic services (such as tourism) cheaper.

Particularly the Greek economy should be happy with a Euro devaluation: it means US, Russian and British tourists and investors would find Greek property and tourism prices that much cheaper, while tourists and investors from the Eurozone would find them unchanged. Yet again: not a single rational analysis of the situation on Greek TV.

Another main event was the results of the NRW election yesterday in Germany. Olga Tremi, who’s fair visage graces this post, could barely conceal the gleam of schadenfreude in her eye as she turned to the report that Angela Merkel’s CDU lost yesterday. The reason stated on both Mega and NET was that this was due to “Merkel’s delayed decision-making on the Greek crisis”.

In fact, nothing could be further from the truth. Yes, some Germans are no doubt angry at her “dithering”. But far more ordinary voters are angry not because she finally voted “yes” to the Greek loan package, but because she did not vote “no”. The Greek media has chosen to ignore the widespread anger among German voters at having to come up with the largest share of loan guarantees—EUR 22 bln—for a profligate, corrupt and politically irresponsible country. Yet somehow, because the CDU was defeated in a single Bundesland, this is somehow a vindication for Greece.

I honestly fail to see how this can be seen as a vindication. Sure, George Papandreou’s strategy from the start has been to internationalise the situation by blaming the “speculators” and calling on Eurozone assistance. But Greece’s debt problems are entirely of its own making. And since the Greek Prime Minister takes every opportunity to state that debt restructuring is not foreseen, this means Greece will pay back 100% of its loans plus interest. The Greek people pay for this, not the CDU or Angela Merkel.

I start work this morning with two parables in mind:

“Don’t bite the hand that feeds you”
“People who live in glass houses should not throw stones”

Will someone please call Olga Tremi and let her know?

Monday, 14 September 2009

Neither PASOK nor ND have a plan to reform the public sector in Greece

ERT Building (c) ERT AE

National elections have been called for October 4th in Greece. For perhaps the first time, both PASOK and ND are vying with each other over who will introduce the most austere budget. This is a welcome change, if it were believable. I believe both party leaders are sincere. But I also believe that the party barons on both sides, as well as decades of vested interest, will sabotage or slow any reform implemented.

What Greece needs is a vision of lean government. Right now, the parties are focussing on top-line, revenue and expenditure assumptions:

• We will freeze public sector salaries
• We will freeze new hiring
• We will crack down on debt avoidance.

Unfortunately, there is no unifying vision or coherence to these measures, or how these would affect the fundamental structure and operations of public administration.

Let us view a simple example. Greece has no fewer than five public broadcast channels. These are bundled under ERT A.E., a public organisation that functions according to private law. ERT A.E. includes the following channels:

• NET
• ERT 1
• ERT 3
• ERT World
• Digital Channels : Prisma, Cine, Spor
• Vouli TV

In addition to this, the government is already funding a range of local authority and municipal TV stations, which mainly transmit programmes of local interest, and occasionally meetings of municipal councils.

The main organisation, ERT, is funded by a mandatory tax on electricity bills. It has some 3,500 employees, and a range of ancillary activities, including several radio stations, a publishing company, and no less than five orchestras:

• National Symphony Orchestra
• Orchestra of Contemporary Music
• ERT Choir
• ERT-3 Orchestra
• Childrens’ Orchestra.

I am a great fan of public TV: in Greece, it is one of the few quasi-objective media organisations (although I am sure this is also open to debate). But frankly, we are in the middle not only of an economic crisis, but of a situation where public debt has reached at least 103% of GDP, and quite possibly 108-110% by the end of 2009. We simply don’t have the resources for massive public sector organisations and repetitive functions which in many cases are paid for by the taxpayer without recourse or choice.

I would expect to see an attempt to transform the Greek public sector using the tools of lean management and e-government. If we take the example of ERT and public media in Greece, I would expect to see the following strategic changes:

1. Greek public TV will comprise 3 channels:

• A national terrestrial broadcaster
• A terrestrial broadcaster oriented towards northern Greece and the Greek islands (ERT 3)
• A digital/satellite broadcaster oriented towards Greeks of the diaspora and equivalent markets

2. All ancillary functions will be divested or closed.

3. All local TV and parliament TV can continue, but will be broadcast only online, and will not be paid for by the central government as a separate item. The costs should be borne by the IT budgets of these organisations, and should be less than EUR 1,000 per organisation from the central budget, with anything remaining gained by sponsorship or advertising.

4. The Greek state will only support a limited number of orchestras, choirs, etc. In any case, the budget for these activities has nothing to do with state television: it should be transferred to the Ministry of Culture. No more than two national symphony orchestras are needed in the entire country: one in Athens; one in Thessaloniki, which are paid for by public funds.

5. The strategic role of the national broadcaster should be to conduct in-depth analyses of Greek history, culture, news, economy, and international relations. We do not need so many programmes on recipes, sports, Greek music, etc. How many separate yet similar programmes on Greek music are aired by ERT, and why are these needed?

6. The headcount of ERT will shrink to 1,250 within 4 years, from the current total of 3,500. The celebrity media culture of untrammelled spending for gossip TV, Eurovision, and other frankly ridiculous events which are currently programmed by ERT must end.

7. Should a public subsidy for ERT continue, it will be collected by the normal tax collection method, and not through DEH (public electricity authority) bills. DEH is a totally separate business, which—apart from convenience—should not function as a billing mechanism for another quasi-governmental organisation. In any case, any public subsidy should be re-channelled to debt reduction, while ERT should improve its already important advertising revenue.

8. All major public debates and decisions should be put online as a matter of course; every Greek (and other) citizen should have access to government through the internet.

Similar decisions are needed in every government or semi-governmental organisation. The time of “caviar socialism” is over: unless hard decisions are made on the basis of a real cost-benefit analysis, the country will soon reach a debt-to-GDP ratio of 140-150%, and it will then be bankrupt.

Greece is spreading its expenditure across thousands of public organisations, replicating a model of government suited to the 1800s of employment and patronage over efficiency. There needs to be a clear strategy of focussing the role of government where it is truly needed, and exiting ancillary functions. Where government is needed, for instance in education, healthcare or the military, then we should spend the correct amount of resources to make sure Greek citizens receive world-class services, not banana republic excuses.

We need to develop a public sector from the ground up, using lean thinking and the power of the internet, if we are to compete, and indeed survive, in the future.

Saturday, 26 January 2008

CNN: What Should be Reported

Since we're on the subject of how to make things better at CNN, here's what I would like to watch, much more than Golfing Minute or Mainsail or The Screening Room or Art of Life or Inside Africa:

1. A real analysis of the US sub-prime crisis
CNN is airing views of various experts and commentators, but we really don't see many hard statistics on the sub-prime mortgage market and the impending ALT-A market, which will be of much larger magnitude than the sub-prime market. I'd like to see a 5-10 minute segment with actual statistics, dealing with the following:

- Approximate loan volume of the sub-prime market
- This loan volume compared to the total mortgage loan market
- Examples of relative interest rate rises after the sub-prime market re-adjusts
- An explanation of loan securitisation and why it's important
- What role the Federal Reserve actually has in regulating bank lending
- Why nothing was done about this, since the problem has been visible for years
- What we should expect with the ALT-A market
- Statistics on the housing market: the Case-Shiller index, the National Association of Realtors statistics on the number of houses sold, new housing starts, number of foreclosures, etc.

All this can be fit into a quick and easy 10-minute segment, with a few slides showing numbers, not just commentary. This information readily available in the Financial Times or the websites of the Case-Schiller Index, the Realtors Association the Federal Reserve, and a few otthers.

We spend hours on the election, but nothing substantial on the economic disaster unfolding before our eyes, which affects millions of American families. Compare Katrina coverage to the real estate crisis. Why the difference?

2. A real analysis of consumer spending and GDP growth in 2008-2009
CNNi has been going wild about Davos, with arguments between CNN anchors and reporters on whether GDP growth in China and India can support world economy growth in the face of a US recession. Of course, no statistics are provided, but this is remarkably easy to compare. Check GDP sizes and growth estimates in 2008 and compare US, Chinese, Indian, and other regional statistics and growth. You can do this in either market rates or Purchasing Power Parity (PPP). Data is available on the World Bank and IMF sites.

You will quickly see that Chinese/Indian consumer spending is not enough to absorb surplus US output, which means trouble for the US and world economy. Given that US companies cannot export enough to China and India (remember the trade deficit?) it's difficult to see how consumer spending in these countries would make up for the US decline in the best case scenario.

Why isn’t this being reported in detail, on the basis of numbers? Why take the risk of potentially misleading the public through totally vague comments?

3. The impacts on the Fed's interest rate drop and the Administration's “stimulus package”
As usual, CNN focuses on the immediate effects of the interest rate drop: stock exchanges stabilise. It does not discuss potential (and probable) longer-term effects of this move:

a. Fewer foreclosures because mortgage rates must go down, since they are linked to the Fed rate. This will likely be the most positive result of the interest rate reduction, not a resumption of consumer spending;

b. A further decline in the US dollar, with lower international purchases of US Treasuries, leading to a worsening problem with funding the $ 7.5 trillion debt as the Treasury will have to offer a higher interest rate to offset declining currency values;

c. An impending shift of Asian and Middle Eastern central banks of their reserves from USD to EUR and other currencies. This will lead to further declines in the USD, and a rise in the EUR. In turn, this will make the EUR less competitive as a currency and damage European economies, which are export-dependent to a much greater extent than the American economy.

4. A real analysis of Republican and Democratic Candidate Health Care & Social Security Plans
Or, for that matter, a serious analysis of any platforms, such as Iraq, the economy, education, the environment, energy security, renewable energy…. anything instead of the campaign soundbites we are currently getting.

5. A serious look at what’s going on internationally
This week, there was a major bomb attack in Lebanon; a pre-announcement about Kosovo’s declaration of independence; a major Russian deal to buy out Serbia’s oil refineries and pipeline complex; major bombing attacks in Iraq (why isn’t Iraq being reported, by the way?); more Turkish incursions into northern Iraq; the resumption of Iranian gas exports via Turkey; Sudan has attacked a UN aid convoy in Darfur….

A lot has happened which is totally off the CNN radar screen. If Kosovo declares independence next week, before the Serbian election, you can bet this will be major news. Yet right now it is ignored, in favour of sensationalist reporting, mainly on the US election, or the Monte Carlo casino fire. This is supposed to be CNN International.

Wednesday, 23 January 2008

CNN: Certainly Not News

Mr. Jim Walton
President
CNN Worldwide
Turner House
16 Great Marlborough Street
London W1F 7HS
United Kingdom


23 January 2007

CNN: Certainly Not News


Dear Mr. Walton,

A confession: I'm a bit of a CNN junkie. When at home in Athens, I usually catch up with news over lunch, and right after dinner. When on the road, it’s usually the last thing I watch on TV. I got to it before the first Gulf War. In those years, it was fresh, innovative, and new.

But then Ted Turner sold out, and Time Warner bought the network, and ever since then it’s been a long downhill slide. Don’t get me wrong: your anchor line-up is still the most fascinating in the business. [Richard Quest? Where did you find this guy?] And it’s still one of the most accessible networks, available on terrestrial channels in most European countries, and satellite channels in Central & Eastern Europe, Russia, and Central Asia. You've got real world-wide coverage, great technology and a strong brand name.

The only problem is, CNN today is all about entertainment, not news. And of the entertainment part, 50% of this is pure narcissism: promoting CNN, and nothing else.

What do you need to do to get back on track, regain credibility with your international audience, and regain your ratings?

Cut the Crap

Golfing Minute, Mainsail, the Screening Room, the Art of Life, Inside Africa, iReport, International Correspondents, Business Traveller, Paging Dr. Gupta, Inside the Middle East, Your World Today, etc. may be lucrative, sponsorship vehicles or vanity programmes, but we don’t care. The only thing that should be kept is standard, plain-vanilla news: Politics, business, current affairs, the economy. Keep the rest on your website, or on the Disney Channel.

End the Weather

Get off this perverse fascination with weather. It seems like every time an anchor needs to take a piss, you put on 5 minutes of weather. Hello? The weather is not news, unless there’s a flood or a hurricane. Didn’t they teach this in journalist school?

Stop the Narcissism

We are sick of Wolf Blitzer going on about “The best political team in business.” We are tired of the constant self-promotion. Your network is not the news.

Get Serious

Tell your anchors to stop smiling and bobbing their heads inanely, especially when they’re reporting human tragedies. Colleen Edwards looks happier than a goose on Prozac, and more power to her, but you shouldn’t be smiling when you’re reporting a car bomb in Baghdad.

Cut Advertising, or be more Selective

Honestly speaking, your advertising stinks. The Artoc Group? The Azerbaijani Tourism Authority? Do you honestly think we care? And stop advertising yourselves all the time. It's pathetic.

Focus on News, Not Glamour

Guys, what happens at Davos is not news. We don’t care, and if we do, we’ll check their website.

Focus on Content, not Style

We’re in the middle of the US primary season, and CNN hasn’t said a single word about the platform of the candidates running for office. Instead, it’s all about appearances: who fell asleep, who burped, who farted, who said what about Martin Luther King. Hello? You call this journalism? I call it a waste of my time and an insult to my intelligence. Why spend so much money on election coverage when you don’t cover the issues? Don't be surprised that CNN is losing ratings.

Retire Larry King

I admire that old goat as much as the next person, but honestly speaking, I’m living in Europe, and I don’t care about Paula Abdul’s career or OJ’s stamp collection or who won American Idol. I still can't get over Larry’s interview of Poppy Bush, who announced that Prescott had gone “straight to heaven”, while Dorothy Bush promoted her hagiography. Wake up, please. We’re not in Kansas anymore.

Stop Repeating Yourselves

Repeating the headlines during your business programmes is not news. You need enough news content to full in a two-hour news cycle. You shouldn’t be airing each recorded piece more than 4 times every 24-hours, and certainly not on each prime time broadcast, unless it’s shocking, sit-up-in-your-seats footage.

The New News Programme

Keep in Simple: Here’s a simple, recession-proof programme:

1. The standard segment should be 12 minutes of news; two minutes of advertising. The sequence should be two 12-minute segments of politics and current affairs; followed by one or two 12-minute segments of business and economy

2. Only four types of news programmes: Headline News, Business News, Election Coverage, Special Features. That's it!

3. Weather: 2 minutes every hour. Sport: 4 minutes every hour. No more!

Keeping it simple will also allow you, forgive me for saying this, to get rid of at least half your anchors, saving a lot of money and removing all this white noise from your programming. Focus on your core mission: reporting world news objectively, comprehensively and up-to-the-minute.

Anchor Advice

1. Get Todd Benjamin to trim his eyebrows: he’s always been the Dirty Harry of business news, but now we can't see his eyes anymore.

2. Get Adrian Finnigan out of the pub and into bed by 22:00 every night: his face is getting more pale and pinched with each broadcast.

3. Retire Ralitsa Vassileva, Brent Sadler, Fionoula Sweeney, and some other old warhorses: they’ve served honourably, dealt with their internal demons and need to get off the air.


I hope this helps. I'm still a captive audience, but if anything else better comes along, you'll lose me in a flash.

Philip